Skip to content
PlanIndex Get alerts
Menu

Planning application

Magnolias Ilsham Marine Drive Torquay TQ1 2PN

Refused Torbay AT/2023/0007 Works To Tree Within TPO

Works: Trees Domestic

Read from the description, not a valuation. How we read the register

Refused. Only the applicant can appeal, within the statutory time limit, and a revised scheme can be submitted instead.

Proposal

Monterey Cypress (Cupressus macrocarpa) (T1) - Fell, height: 20m, Crown spread N:5m, S:3m, E:6m, W:4m The primary concern regarding the tree is its safety when considering its proximity to the property (6m). The tree is inclined towards the building and is growing in a dominant elevated position atop a bank in an area susceptible to high winds. If the tree should fail, it would strike the dwelling. The loading and weight is biased towards the property with the crown of the tree extending towards the accommodation. The height of the tree can be considered oppressive and has an impact on the owners ability to enjoy the safe use of their accommodation. The tree is interefing with the property owner's amenity and enjoyment of their property and creating a private nuisance due to: - Stress caused during periods of high winds (property owner is avoiding using rooms that are closest to the tree) - A significant obstruction of natural light In order to fully abate these concerns we would request to remove the tree and replace with a smaller tree appropriate for the space and location. See tree report for further assessment.

As published by the council, reference AT/2023/0007

Application record

Reference
AT/2023/0007
Type
Works To Tree Within TPO
Status
Decided
Decision
Refused As published: Refusal
Received
10 Jan 2023
Validated
17 Jan 2023
Decided
8 Mar 2023
Ward
Wellswood
Decision by
Delegated
Postcode
TQ1 2PN

Timeline

Dates from the published record

  1. 10 Jan 2023

    Received by Torbay

  2. 17 Jan 2023

    Validated

    Checked as complete and ready for consideration.

  3. 8 Mar 2023

    Decision issued: Refusal

  4. 1 Aug 2026

    Added to PlanIndex

Documents

5 documents on file for this application

A planning file usually holds the application form, the consultee responses, the officer's report and the decision notice.

Watch members (£5 a month) open the document list from here.

Open the documents

Working a patch? Trade sends you every new job in your area each morning. 14 days free.

What this refusal means

Torbay refused this application for the reasons on the decision notice; only the applicant can appeal, and refused schemes often return in revised form. More in our guide to what happens after a planning decision.

About tree works applications

Applications for works to trees cover protected trees: consent under a tree preservation order, or six weeks notice for trees in a conservation area. More in our guide to planning application types.

Nearby applications

Within 0.3 miles

  • Stoodley Knowle School Ansteys Cove Road Torquay TQ1 2JB

    P/2022/1165 Submitted 25 Oct 2022 50 yards away

    Installation of mobile sales unit with associated access and landscaping (Retrospective).

    Granted Full applications 13 docs
  • Arbour House Ilsham Marine Drive Torquay TQ1 2PN

    P/2024/0539 Submitted 8 Aug 2024 50 yards away

    Variation of Condition relating to application P/2023/1020: Alterations and reconstruction of the northwest extension, change of external materials, removal of chimney and changes to fenestration. Condition: P1 - Approved Plans. Variation sought: minor design variations.

    Granted Amendments Extension Windows or glazing 10 docs
  • 117 Ilsham Road Torquay TQ1 2HY

    P/2021/0556 Submitted 10 May 2021 100 yards away

    Extensions & alterations to include extensions to front, sides & rear. Formation of terrace to rear & parking area to front. Alterations to roof, doors, windows & associated works.

    Granted Householder Extension Windows or glazing 19 docs
    Domestic
  • 123 Ilsham Road Torquay TQ1 2HY

    AT/2023/0144 Submitted 15 May 2023 100 yards away

    We would like to apply to have the large Ash removed due to Ash die back, last summer all the Ash trees were removed on Ilsham green, we have spoke to High Line and they kindly confirmed the Ash had Ash die back and was in a bit of a poor state and therefore we would like to seek permission for the complete removal of the tree to ground level as per the works carried out on Ilsham Green.

    Granted Trees 9 docs
  • 48 Ilsham Road Torquay TQ1 2HY

    AT/2023/0087 Submitted 23 Mar 2023 150 yards away

    T1- Beech- crown reduce by 2 meters to allow more light into the property and make the garden more useable. T2- eucalyptus- 3 meter reduction due to the lean and basal rot, this is to reduce the weight on the tree a lower the likelihood of failure.

    Refused Trees 4 docs
  • Aquarius Ilsham Marine Drive Torquay TQ1 2PN

    AT/2024/0336 Submitted 12 Dec 2024 150 yards away

    Beech (T1) fell due to the presence of Gandorema spp. fruit bodies, which compromised the integrity of the wood in the buttress. Mrs Yeo expressed concerns that it could potentially fall onto neighbouring properties. The recommendation is to mechanically remove the tree stump and replant with fastigiate oak.

    Granted Trees

In Torbay

  • AT/2026/0257 Granted

    White Rock Primary School Davies Avenue Paignton TQ4 7AW

    T12 - 1x Common Ash Fraxinus excelsior What3Words Location ///ultra.clay.utter Remove tree to ground level. T14 - 1x Elm Tree Ulmus sp. What3Words Location ///florists.stooping.tempting Fell tree to ground level. T1631 - 1x Common Ash Trees Fraxinus excelsior What3Words Location ///bicker.mouse.valuables Sectionally dismantle, fell, and remove to ground level using appropriate rigging and lowering techniques where necessary to ensure the safe and controlled removal of all sections in accordance with industry best practice. T15 - 1x Scots Pine (Pinus sylvestris) ///footballers.such.press Sectionally dismantle, fell, and remove to ground level using appropriate rigging and lowering techniques where necessary to ensure the safe and controlled removal of all sections in accordance with industry best practice. Wood chippings arising from the works shall be spread neatly within the adjacent woodland area where appropriate. All logwood and excess arising material shall be removed from site. See report and schedules for reasons

    Received 18 Sep, published by the council 23 Sep 2026 Trees
  • AT/2026/0254 Granted

    Singleton Manor Singleton Higher Woodfield Road Torquay TQ1 2LE

    1. T776 Holm Oak - fell 2. T780 Sycamore - fell 3. T781 Turkey Oak - fell 4. T783 Ash - fell

    Received 17 Sep, published by the council 23 Sep 2026 Trees
  • AT/2026/0255 Granted

    Little Spinney Windsor Road Torquay TQ1 1SW

    T1 Beech - fell

    Received 17 Sep, published by the council 23 Sep 2026 Trees
  • AT/2026/0247 Granted

    24 Brunel Road Paignton TQ4 6HN

    Consent was granted under application reference AT/2023/0008; however, the approved tree works were not undertaken. Ash T1 fell to near-ground level. The slender tree shows symptoms consistent with Ash Dieback (Hymenoscyphus fraxineus), including crown thinning, deadwood, and progressive structural decline. Sycamore T2 Fell. A Tree Preservation Order was made in 1984. The current dimensions suggest the tree became established after that date, so the proposed felling can be considered. Mixed species G1 Fell. A Tree Preservation Order was made in 1984. The current dimensions suggest the trees became established after that date, so the proposed felling can be considered.

    Received 15 Sep, published by the council 23 Sep 2026 Trees
  • AT/2026/0200 Refused

    2 Cecil Avenue Paignton TQ3 1LW

    T1. Mature sweet chestnut on the SW boundary /individual TPO(1999.012): Current height: 13m, current spread: 10m Proposed works: Crown reduction to result in a height of 11m and a spread of 7m T2. Mature sweet chestnut on the NE boundary bank. It stands at the edge just within the area TPO(1979.003) and within the neighbour's property as follows: Mr S Congdon, Lydford House, Barcombe Heights,Preston, Paignton. Current height: 14m, current spread: 10m Proposed works: Crown reduction to result in a height of 12m and a spread of 8m. Spread to be reduced up to 2m only on the S.E., S. and S.W. aspects of the crown. Remove basal shoots including 1x limb of 15cm dbh that grows at the base of the trunk.

    Received 29 Jul, published by the council 23 Sep 2026 Trees