Planning application
Vine House, Brightwell Street, Brightwell cum Sotwell, Wallingford, OX10 0RU
Works: Trees
Decided. The decision notice on the council portal carries the outcome in full, including any conditions.
Proposal
T3 - Silver Birch T11, T12, T13, T14 - Scots Pine T3 - Silver Birch - twin stem tree with included bark. We have considered fitting a brace, but have been advised it would confirm we acknowledge there is a weakness in the tree which may bring into question the liability for damage in the event it falls. With south westerly prevailing winds the most likely direction of fall for this tree if it did go would be onto the neighbour's outbuilding and/or conservatory. I have concluded therefore, reluctantly, that this tree should be felled. T11, 12, 13, 14 - Scots Pine - the remaining 4 of 17 or more originally planted on edge of orchard. Pines now shade out fruit trees - one plum tree has died back considerably. Tree T14 has a split stem about half way up. Intention T11, T12 & T13 - lift canopy to 5m above ground. T14 - fell to ground. Remarks:
As published by the council, reference P18/S4391/TCA
Application record
- Reference
- P18/S4391/TCA
- Type
- Works to trees in CA
- Status
- Decision Made
- Decision
- No obj CA works
- Received
- 13 Feb 2018
- Validated
- 13 Feb 2018
- Decided
- 28 Feb 2018
- Postcode
- OX10 0RU
Site history
Applications at this address on the South Oxfordshire register
This site has had 2 applications since 2017.
-
P17/S4901/TCA Decided
Vine House, Brightwell Street, Brightwell cum Sotwell, Wallingford, OX10 0RU
T1 - Silver Birch T2 - Cherry Plum T3 - Silver Birch T4 - Copper Beech T5 - Robinia T6 - Robinia T7 - Lombardy Poplar T8 - Willow T9 - Silver Birch T10 - Walnut T11, 12, 13, 14 - Scots Pine T15 - Walnut T1 - Silver Birch - very close to the house and by the main village road this ill placed tree is now oversized for its location. High sided vehicles catch it in passing, especially the regular milk tanker. Year on year the autumn leaf causes blocked gutters on the house and slippery leaf debris on the road and pavement. Autumn leaf and winter stick debris on the road risk blocking drains. The tree leans towards the road, recently during Storm Brian the lean became worse and some ground heave was noted. Risk of falling onto road? Intention: Fell to ground level. T2 - Cherry Plum - this very old tree has been dying back bit by bit over the years. Branches grow out into the neighbours parking area causing scratch damage to his vehicles. Intention: fell to ground level. T3 - Silver Birch - Lower branches catch the neighbours shed roof risking damage, some gutter blockage caused. Tree shades neighbours garden. Intention: crown clean to remove dead and crossing branches, thin crown 25% to allow light for neighbour, and raise crown to 5m to clear neighbours shed. T4 - Copper Beech - oversized for its location. Taking light from neighbour's garden in summer. Overcrowding neighbouring ash and yew. Intention: crown clean and reduction to about 40ft height - where stem splits and crown is restricted by neighbouring ash tree. T5 - Robinia - oversized for location, risk of damaging fence. Intention: crown clean to remove and dead and crossing branches, crown reduction to 25ft. T6 - Robinia - oversized for location, damagig fence and neighbours shed roof. Multi-stemmed - one stem has already broken fence panel and post. Intention: remove stem damaging fence, crown clean to remove dead and crossing branchs, crown reduction to 25 ft and remove branches affecting shed. T7 - Lombardy Poplar - growing through pub car park tarmac from root of tree originally in our garden and felled 14 years ago approx. Tree damages car park surface, stems pushing fence panels over, leaf and stick fall affects parking area, trunk reduces parking space. Intention: fell to ground level. T8 - Willow - large old tree reaching end of natural life. Oversized for its position. Rot in some limbs. Cracks appearing in limbs and risk of limbs/branches splitting and falling. Intention: fell to ground. T9 - Silver Birch - tall tree exposed to prevailing wind. Damaged by falling tree in storm in 2002. Leans, and ground heave now evident during strong winds. Intention: fell to ground. T10 - Walnut - large tree on edge of orchard now overcrowding and shading fruit trees. Intention: remove one limb to balance tree, crown clean to remove dead and crossing branches, crown reduction to about 40 ft, lift canopy above shed roof. T11, 12, 13, & 14 - Scots Pine - the remaining 4 of 17 or more originally planted on edge of orchard. Pines now shade out fruit trees - one plum tree has died back considerably - and compete for space with walnut trees. Intention: retain T12, Fell tree 11, 13 and 14. T15 - Walnut - large tree on edge of orchard and boundary with neighbours garden. Overcrowding and shading fruit trees. Lower branches interfere with neighbours shed roofs and trees. Intention: raise canopy to clear neighbour's sheds, crown clean to remove dead branches, crown reduction to about 40 ft to reduce shading of fruit trees. Remarks:
Timeline
Dates from the published record
-
13 Feb 2018
Received by South Oxfordshire
-
28 Feb 2018
Decision issued: No obj CA works
-
15 Aug 2026
Added to PlanIndex
Documents
Plans, drawings, consultee responses and the officer's report
2 documents on file for this application
A planning file usually holds the application form, drawings and site plans, consultee responses, the officer's report and the decision notice.
Trade members open them from here.
Open the documentsAfter the decision
South Oxfordshire has decided this application; the outcome above is the register's own wording and the decision notice on the council portal carries the detail. More in our guide to what happens after a planning decision.
About tree works applications
Applications for works to trees cover protected trees: consent under a tree preservation order, or six weeks notice for trees in a conservation area. More in our guide to planning application types.
Nearby applications
Within 500 metres
-
Strathdene West End Brightwell-cum-Sotwell OX10 0RU
Demolition of existing dwelling and construction of replacement dwelling. (as amended by drgwnos K1870-02-102 A, K1870-02-103 A and K1870- 02-104 A to remove rear facing upper storey dormer window and replace with a roof light received on 18 June 2019)
Decided Full applications Loft or dormer Demolition +1 18 docsDomestic -
Strathdene West End Brightwell-Cum-Sotwell OX10 0RU
Two storey side extension, Conversion of existing roof space to habitable use including raising existing ridge height. Resiting front door to front elevation with canopy. Render to be applied to existing external walls.
Withdrawn Householder Extension Roofing 14 docsDomestic -
St Cecilia West End Brightwell-cum-Sotwell OX10 0RU
Replacement of existing conservatory and sitting with single storey rear extension (as clarified by Arboricultural Method Statement FINAL, Arboricultural Survey FINAL, Arb Survey drwgno 17045-100 & Tree Protection plan drwgno 17045-110 received on 30 October 2017)
Withdrawn Householder Extension Trees 12 docsSmall domestic -
Vine House, Brightwell Street, Brightwell cum Sotwell, Wallingford, OX10 0RU
T1 - Silver Birch T2 - Cherry Plum T3 - Silver Birch T4 - Copper Beech T5 - Robinia T6 - Robinia T7 - Lombardy Poplar T8 - Willow T9 - Silver Birch T10 - Walnut T11, 12, 13, 14 - Scots Pine T15 - Walnut T1 - Silver Birch - very close to the house and by the main village road this ill placed tree is now oversized for its location. High sided vehicles catch it in passing, especially the regular milk tanker. Year on year the autumn leaf causes blocked gutters on the house and slippery leaf debris on the road and pavement. Autumn leaf and winter stick debris on the road risk blocking drains. The tree leans towards the road, recently during Storm Brian the lean became worse and some ground heave was noted. Risk of falling onto road? Intention: Fell to ground level. T2 - Cherry Plum - this very old tree has been dying back bit by bit over the years. Branches grow out into the neighbours parking area causing scratch damage to his vehicles. Intention: fell to ground level. T3 - Silver Birch - Lower branches catch the neighbours shed roof risking damage, some gutter blockage caused. Tree shades neighbours garden. Intention: crown clean to remove dead and crossing branches, thin crown 25% to allow light for neighbour, and raise crown to 5m to clear neighbours shed. T4 - Copper Beech - oversized for its location. Taking light from neighbour's garden in summer. Overcrowding neighbouring ash and yew. Intention: crown clean and reduction to about 40ft height - where stem splits and crown is restricted by neighbouring ash tree. T5 - Robinia - oversized for location, risk of damaging fence. Intention: crown clean to remove and dead and crossing branches, crown reduction to 25ft. T6 - Robinia - oversized for location, damagig fence and neighbours shed roof. Multi-stemmed - one stem has already broken fence panel and post. Intention: remove stem damaging fence, crown clean to remove dead and crossing branchs, crown reduction to 25 ft and remove branches affecting shed. T7 - Lombardy Poplar - growing through pub car park tarmac from root of tree originally in our garden and felled 14 years ago approx. Tree damages car park surface, stems pushing fence panels over, leaf and stick fall affects parking area, trunk reduces parking space. Intention: fell to ground level. T8 - Willow - large old tree reaching end of natural life. Oversized for its position. Rot in some limbs. Cracks appearing in limbs and risk of limbs/branches splitting and falling. Intention: fell to ground. T9 - Silver Birch - tall tree exposed to prevailing wind. Damaged by falling tree in storm in 2002. Leans, and ground heave now evident during strong winds. Intention: fell to ground. T10 - Walnut - large tree on edge of orchard now overcrowding and shading fruit trees. Intention: remove one limb to balance tree, crown clean to remove dead and crossing branches, crown reduction to about 40 ft, lift canopy above shed roof. T11, 12, 13, & 14 - Scots Pine - the remaining 4 of 17 or more originally planted on edge of orchard. Pines now shade out fruit trees - one plum tree has died back considerably - and compete for space with walnut trees. Intention: retain T12, Fell tree 11, 13 and 14. T15 - Walnut - large tree on edge of orchard and boundary with neighbours garden. Overcrowding and shading fruit trees. Lower branches interfere with neighbours shed roofs and trees. Intention: raise canopy to clear neighbour's sheds, crown clean to remove dead branches, crown reduction to about 40 ft to reduce shading of fruit trees. Remarks:
Decided Trees 2 docsSmall domestic -
Strathdene West End Brightwell-cum-Sotwell OX10 0RU
Discharge of condition 3 (Schedule of Materials) to planning application P19/S1128/FUL Demolition of existing dwelling and construction of replacement dwelling. (as amended by drgwnos K1870-02-102 A, K1870-02-103 A and K1870- 02-104 A to remove rear facing upper storey dormer window and replace with a roof light received on 18 June 2019)
Decided Conditions Loft or dormer Demolition +1 3 docsDomestic -
Strathdene West End Brightwell-cum-Sotwell OX10 0RU
Discharge of condition 7 Tree Protection (General) of planning permission P19/S1128/FUL Demolition of existing dwelling and construction of replacement dwelling. (as amended by drgwnos K1870-02-102 A, K1870-02-103 A and K1870- 02-104 A to remove rear facing upper storey dormer window and replace with a roof light received on 18 June 2019)
Decided Conditions Loft or dormer Demolition +2 3 docsDomestic
Other tree works applications
In South Oxfordshire
-
P26/S3819/TCA Decided
The Old Saddlery The Green Great Milton Oxford OX44 7NT
T1, Silver Birch, historic heavy pruning by utility company. Reduce tree to manage its canopy by pruning 1 metre or as available pruning points dictate
-
P26/S3436/TPO Granted
The Mill Sonning Eye Reading RG4 6TY
Tree 1 London plane - Requires crown lift of the small diameter branches above the front car park and near to the main entrance to the theatre. Ideally 5 metre clearance is required for delivery vehicles and coaches. Small diameter branches that are close to the building need pruning to give 2 metre clearance. Remove deadwood from higher up and inspect the tree for signs of hollowing or disease.
-
P26/S3948/TCA Decided
Iden House Bakers Lane Brightwell-cum-sotwell Wallingford OX10 0PY
T1 poplar fell to ground, due to the proximity to neighbouring properties and a concern from the homeowner regarding the overall size of the tree
-
P26/S3880/TCA Decided
The Mill Sonning Eye Reading RG4 6TY
(T2) Ash - Requires crown lift of the small diameter branches above car park to provide 5 metre clearance for delivery and waste collection vehicles. Small diameter branches close to the building need pruning to give a 2 metre clearance to help prevent damage to the sloped roof. Remove deadwood. (T3) Horse chestnut - Requires crown lift of the small diameter branches above car park area to give a 4 metre clearance for cars and vans. Remove deadwood. (T4) Ash - Originally listed as a Willow tree by mistake. Requires pollarding at suitable point at approximately 3 metres above ground level. The tree has good regrowth lower down and is ideal for this procedure.
-
P26/S3143/TPO Granted
Black Gables 14 Rotherfield Road Henley-on-thames RG9 1NN
G1 Various species. Down track between properties. - Prune back from gutters. Prune branches to provide a clearance of approximately 0.5-1.0m. This will target tertiary & secondary branches. Where thought necessary this may entail the removal of small diameter (<60mm) primary branches so as not to introduce large wounds close to the stem of the tree. G2 Various species. Front drive to house. - Prune branches to provide a clearance of approximately 5.0m over the driveway. This will target tertiary & secondary branches. Where thought necessary this may entail the removal of small diameter (<60mm) primary branches so as not to introduce large wounds close to the stem of the tree. T1 Maple. Centre front lawn - Prune branches to provide a clearance of approximately 2.5m over the lawn area. This will target tertiary & secondary branches. Where thought necessary this may entail the removal of small diameter (<60mm) primary branches so as not to introduce large wounds close to the stem of the tree. G3 Various species. RHS path into the rear garden - Prune & trim to provide a clearance of approximately 1.0m from the roof line and gutters. This action will remove up to 1.5m of lower lateral branch growth. - Prune back to path edging where possible, by removal of up to 0.5m where via a combination of hedge cutting and light pruning. - Prune Lime trees to approximately 5.0m fgl (from ground level) to clear roof line - This will target tertiary & secondary branches. Where thought necessary this may entail the removal of small diameter (<60mm) primary branches so as not to introduce large wounds close to the stem of the tree. T2 Oak. 1st Oak RHS rear garden. - Prune epicormic growth back to source up to crown break. - Lightly prune to provide a clearance of up to 1.0 m from the Amelanchier. This will target tertiary & secondary branches. Where thought necessary this may entail the removal of small diameter (<60mm) primary branches so as not to introduce large wounds close to the stem of the tree. T3 Oak. 2nd Oak RHS of rear garden. - Prune epicormic growth back to source up to crown break. T4 Yew. RHS of T3. - Light reduction of the top edge to blend into remaining upper crown. This action will remove up to 0.5m of garden side lateral growth. T5 Oak. On the LHS of the rear garden - Prune epicormic growth back to source up to crown break. - Prune branches to provide a clearance of approximately 4.5m over the lawn area. This will target tertiary & secondary branches. Where thought necessary this may entail the removal of small diameter (<60mm) primary branches so as not to introduce large wounds close to the stem of the tree. T6 Sycamore. LHS rear garden behind T5. - Prune branches to provide a clearance of approximately 4.5m over the shrub bed areas. This will target tertiary & secondary branches. Where thought necessary this may entail the removal of small diameter (<60mm) primary branches so as not to introduce large wounds close to the stem of the tree.