Planning application
406 Old Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3QF
Works: Trees
Refused. Only the applicant can appeal, within the statutory time limit, and a revised scheme can be submitted instead.
Proposal
Pines (TG1) - fell close to ground level Pine (T1) T2 T3 - fell close to ground level Pine (T2) - fell close to ground level Pine (T3) - fell close to ground level 1. The above tree works are proposed as a remedy to the differential foundation movement at the insured property and to ensure the long-term stability of the building. 2. The above tree works are proposed to limit the extent and need for expensive and disruptive engineering repair works at the insured property. In this instance the estimated repair costs are likely to vary between ?25,000 and ?75,000, depending upon whether the tree/s can be removed or must remain. 3. The above tree works are proposed to limit the duration of any claim period and therefore allow the landowner their right to the peaceful enjoyment of their property. 4. It is the case that an alternative to felling such as pruning or significant 'pollarding' of the tree would not provide a reliable or sustainable remedy to the subsidence in this case. We do not consider that any other potential means of mitigation, including root barriers, would be effective or appropriate in the circumstances. 5. We are satisfied that the evidence obtained following completion of our Arboricultural Implication Assessment report completed 18th July 2019, clearly links the Pine trees as the cause of damage to the risk address 6. Insurers understanding the requirement to offer replacement planting in the event consent to fell is granted.
As published by the council, reference CHE/19/00633/TPO
Application record
- Reference
- CHE/19/00633/TPO
- Type
- Tree Preservation Order
- Status
- Decided
- Decision
- Refused As published: refused
- Received
- 11 Oct 2019
- Validated
- 11 Oct 2019
- Decided
- 2 Dec 2019
- Ward
- West
- Decision by
- Delegated Decision
- Postcode
- S40 3QF
Timeline
Dates from the published record
-
11 Oct 2019
Received by North East Derbyshire
-
2 Dec 2019
Decision issued: refused
-
14 Aug 2026
Added to PlanIndex
Who's behind it
Company information only, from the register and Companies House
Property Risk Inspection Ltd Applicant, registered in Colchester
Active · incorporated 2014 · Colchester
9 applications on PlanIndex · across 7 councils
Trade members see everything this firm has filed, how it was decided, and get an email the day it files again.
See their track recordDocuments
Plans, drawings, consultee responses and the officer's report
8 documents on file for this application
- STRUCTURAL ENGINNERS REPORT
- 138048 ENGINEERING APPRAISAL REPORT
- 138048 LEVEL MONITORING
- 138048 PRI ARB REPORT
- 138048 SITE INVESTIGATION REPORT
- 138048 TPO STATEMENT OF REASONS
- SITE PLAN
- APPLICATIONFORM
Watch members (£5 a month) open the document list from here.
Open the documentsWhat this refusal means
North East Derbyshire refused this application for the reasons on the decision notice; only the applicant can appeal, and refused schemes often return in revised form. More in our guide to what happens after a planning decision.
About tree works applications
Applications for works to trees cover protected trees: consent under a tree preservation order, or six weeks notice for trees in a conservation area. More in our guide to planning application types.
Nearby applications
Within 0.3 miles
-
396 Old Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3QF
Beech (TGI) Reduce Height 6 Metres Reduce Sides 2 Metres
Granted Trees 1 doc -
406 Old Road Chesterfield S40 3QF
The works involve installing a root barrier to separate trees from building due to the subsidence damage observed at the property. The council has been made aware of the damage in applications 19/0633 and 20/00817 and all relevant information is provided with this application. Details of the barrier in terms of its length, depth and distance from trees are shown in the attached arboricultural method statement.
Granted Trees 10 docs -
406 Old Road Chesterfield S40 3QF
The works involve installing a root barrier to separate trees from building due to the subsidence damage observed at the property. The council has been made aware of the damage in applications 19/0633 and 20/00817 and all relevant information is provided with this application. Details of the barrier in terms of its length, depth and distance from trees are shown in the attached arboricultural method statement.
Granted Trees 10 docs -
406 Old Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3QF
Pines (TG1) - fell close to ground level Pine (T1) T2 T3 - fell close to ground level Pine (T2) - fell close to ground level Pine (T3) - fell close to ground level 1. The above tree works are proposed as a remedy to the differential foundation movement at the insured property and to ensure the long-term stability of the building. 2. The above tree works are proposed to limit the extent and need for expensive and disruptive engineering repair works at the insured property. In this instance the estimated repair costs are likely to vary between ?25,000 and ?75,000, depending upon whether the tree/s can be removed or must remain. 3. The above tree works are proposed to limit the duration of any claim period and therefore allow the landowner their right to the peaceful enjoyment of their property. 4. It is the case that an alternative to felling such as pruning or significant 'pollarding' of the tree would not provide a reliable or sustainable remedy to the subsidence in this case. We do not consider that any other potential means of mitigation, including root barriers, would be effective or appropriate in the circumstances. 5. We are satisfied that the evidence obtained following completion of our Arboricultural Implication Assessment report completed 18th July 2019, clearly links the Pine trees as the cause of damage to the risk address 6. Insurers understanding the requirement to offer replacement planting in the event consent to fell is granted.
Refused Trees 8 docs -
398 Old Road Chesterfield S40 3QF
Demolition of existing conservatory and replacement garden room, porch and 3 dormer windows to rear elevation.
Granted Full applications Extension Loft or dormer +2 20 docsSmall domestic -
398 Old Road Chesterfield S40 3QF
Demolition of existing conservatory and replacement garden room, porch and 3 dormer windows to rear elevation.
Granted Full applications Extension Loft or dormer +2 20 docsSmall domestic
Other tree works applications
In North East Derbyshire
-
CHE/26/00682/TPO Granted
63 The Green Hasland Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 0LW
Works to T33 (Beech)
-
CHE/26/00695/TPO Granted
39 Coupland Close Old Whittington Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 9TB
Works to T55 (Sycamore)
-
CHE/26/00685/TPO Granted
19 Penmore Lane & 134 Hasland Road Hasland Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 0SG & S41 0AB
Fell T1 Lime and works to T2 Sycamore
-
CHE/26/00746/CA Granted
52 Sheffield Road Stonegravels Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 7LR
To remove x3 medium Ash trees that have ash dieback
-
CHE/26/00649/TPO Split decision
178 Broomhill Road Old Whittington Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 9EB
Removal of T1 Ash Franxinus excelsior & Removal of T2 Sycamore Acer pseudoplantus