Skip to content
PlanIndex Get alerts
Menu

Planning application

Land Adjacent To 1 Swains End Swains Road Bembridge Isle Of Wight

Refused Isle of Wight 20/00530/FUL Full Planning Permission

Works: Trees Domestic

Read from the description, not a valuation. How we read the register

Refused. Only the applicant can appeal, within the statutory time limit, and a revised scheme can be submitted instead.

Proposal

Proposed dwelling (revised scheme)(tree and ecology information available)(readvertised application)

As published by the council, reference 20/00530/FUL

Application record

Reference
20/00530/FUL
Type
Full Planning Permission
Status
Decided
Decision
Refused
Received
20 Mar 2020
Validated
20 Mar 2020
Decided
30 Jul 2021
Ward
Brading, St. Helens And Bembridge
Parish
Bembridge
Decision by
Planning Officer Delegated Decision

Site history

Applications at this address on the Isle of Wight register

This site has had 3 applications since 2020: 1 approved, 1 refused.

  • 26/01201/CLPUD Awaiting decision

    Land Adjacent To 1 Swains End Swains Road Bembridge Isle Of Wight

    Lawful Development Certificate for proposed replacement static caravan

    Submitted 1 Sep 2026 Outline
  • 25/01254/TW Granted

    Land Adjacent To 1 Swains End Swains Road Bembridge Isle Of Wight

    Amendments to proposed works (18/11/205): T1; Monterey cyprus (south west corner) - Full removal of end tree of group. T2; Monterey cyprus (next to T3 along boundary) - Full removal. T3; Sycamore (along footpath - southern boundary mid-way) - Full removal. T4; Sycamore (by postbox corner) - Full removal. T5; Sycamore (along wall to sea) - Reduce by half.

    Decided 21 Nov 2025 Trees

Timeline

Dates from the published record

  1. 20 Mar 2020

    Received by Isle of Wight

  2. 30 Jul 2021

    Decision issued: Refused

  3. 27 Jul 2026

    Added to PlanIndex

Cases linked to this one on the register

  • Appeal: 21/00075/REF (Appeal In Progress)

Who's behind it

Company information only, from the register and Companies House

Phil Salmon Planning Ltd Agent, a planning consultancy registered in Newport

Active · incorporated 2013 · Newport

43 applications on PlanIndex · across 5 councils · 64% granted

Trade members see everything this firm has filed, how it was decided, and get an email the day it files again.

See their track record

Documents

Plans, drawings, consultee responses and the officer's report

60 documents on file for this application

  • DECISION NOTICE REFUSAL Decision Notice - Refused · 30 Jul 2021
  • ECOLOGY OFFICER Consultee Comment · 05 Feb 2021
  • MR BEMBRIDGE PARISH COUNCIL-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 03 Jun 2020
  • MR JERRY WILLIS Consultee Comment · 27 May 2020
  • APPROPRIATE ASSESSMENT Other · 12 May 2020
  • SOUTHERN WATER Consultee Comment · 07 May 2020
  • MR BEMBRIDGE PARISH COUNCIL-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 05 May 2020
  • MR TREVOR HUMPHREYS-NEUTRAL(FULL) Public Comment · 04 May 2020
  • MR STUART AIKEN-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 04 May 2020
  • MRS PATRICIA SAUL-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 03 May 2020
  • MRS SARAH FREMANTLE-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 01 May 2020
  • DAVID LONG, BCM Public Comment · 30 Apr 2020
  • RIGHTS OF WAY Consultee Comment · 30 Apr 2020
  • MISS GRACE BOOTH Consultee Comment · 28 Apr 2020
  • MR ANDREW SYMINGTON-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 28 Apr 2020
  • MR GRAHAM LEE BADGER TRUST IW-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 27 Apr 2020
  • OTHER IAN CHESHIRE-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 27 Apr 2020
  • MRS SUSIE BEART-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 27 Apr 2020
  • MR HUGH BOYNTON-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 27 Apr 2020
  • MR DOMINIC SAMUELSON-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 27 Apr 2020
  • MRS CARINA ARNELL THE BADGER TRUST IW-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 26 Apr 2020
  • MR WILLIAM BLAND-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 24 Apr 2020
  • MR IAIN YOUNG-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 24 Apr 2020
  • MRS D GRIMALDI-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 24 Apr 2020
  • MR SAM HALL-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 24 Apr 2020
  • MISS ALICIA GRIMALDI-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 23 Apr 2020
  • MR GARETH LEWIS-SUPPORTS(FULL) Public Comment · 23 Apr 2020
  • DR JAMES MALLINSON-SUPPORTS(FULL) Public Comment · 23 Apr 2020
  • MR & MRS A PAUL Public Comment · 23 Apr 2020
  • MRS CAROLYN HOLBROOK-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 23 Apr 2020
  • MRS SOPHIA PARTRIDGE-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 23 Apr 2020
  • MS MIRANA DEVAS-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 22 Apr 2020
  • MRS CARINA SANER-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 22 Apr 2020
  • MR ALASTAIR GORNALL-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 21 Apr 2020
  • MR MALCOLM PAUL-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 16 Apr 2020
  • MRS PENNY WELTON-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 15 Apr 2020
  • MR PETER GRIMALDI-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 13 Apr 2020
  • OTHER HARRIET BRABAZON-OBJECTS(FULL) Public Comment · 13 Apr 2020
  • ISLAND ROADS Consultee Comment · 27 Mar 2020
  • ENERGY MODELLING AND PASSIVHOUSE DESIGN Supporting Information · 25 Mar 2020
  • SITE NOTICE Site Notice · 24 Mar 2020
  • 010 EXISTING PLAN(2) Plans - Other · 20 Mar 2020
  • 020 PROPOSED PLAN REV E(3) Plans - Other · 20 Mar 2020
  • 022 PROPOSED PLAN INTERNAL REV A(1) Plans - Other · 20 Mar 2020
  • 023 PROPOSED ELEVATIONS N S REV B(1) Plans - Other · 20 Mar 2020
  • 024 PROPOSED ELEVATIONS E W REV A(1) Plans - Other · 20 Mar 2020
  • 021 PROPOSED SITE ELEVATION REV B(1) Plans - Other · 20 Mar 2020
  • 011 EXISTING SITE ELEVATION(1) Plans - Other · 20 Mar 2020
  • 025 SECTION(1) Plans - Other · 20 Mar 2020
  • SWAINS ROAD BATS TREE SURVEY Supporting Information · 20 Mar 2020
  • 020 PROPOSED PLAN REV E(2) Plan - Block · 20 Mar 2020
  • APPLICATION STATEMENT REVISED SCHEME SWAINS RD BEMBRIDGE SUBMISSION MARCH 2020 S Supporting Information · 20 Mar 2020
  • 010 EXISTING PLAN(1) Plan - Site · 20 Mar 2020
  • BLOCK AND LOCATION PLAN Plan - Location · 20 Mar 2020
  • BLOCK AND LOCATION PLAN(1) Plan - Location · 20 Mar 2020
  • APP 4 TSP SWAINS RD BEMBRIDGE 10 4 18 Supporting Information · 20 Mar 2020
  • APP 5 TCP SWAINS RD BEMBRIDGE 18 3 20 REV A Supporting Information · 20 Mar 2020
  • ARB REPORT TREE SURVEY SWAINS RD BEMBRIDGE 11 4 18 REV B Supporting Information · 20 Mar 2020
  • ATTACHMENTSUMMARY Supporting Information · 20 Mar 2020
  • APPLICATIONFORMREDACTED Application Form - Public Copy · 20 Mar 2020

Watch members (£5 a month) open the document list from here.

Open the documents

What this refusal means

Isle of Wight refused this application for the reasons on the decision notice; only the applicant can appeal, and refused schemes often return in revised form. More in our guide to what happens after a planning decision.

About full applications

A full application seeks permission for a complete, detailed proposal in one go, with siting, design, access and landscaping all fixed at this stage. More in our guide to planning application types.

Nearby applications

Within 0.3 miles

  • Land Adjacent To 1-2 Swains Villas Swains Road Bembridge Isle Of Wight

    24/01721/CLEUD Submitted 14 Nov 2024 50 yards away

    Lawful Development Certificate for continued siting of caravan for use as self contained dwelling

    Refused Lawful development 19 docs
    Domestic

  • Land Adjacent To 1 Swains End Swains Road Bembridge Isle Of Wight

    25/01254/TW Submitted 1 Sep 2025 50 yards away

    Amendments to proposed works (18/11/205): T1; Monterey cyprus (south west corner) - Full removal of end tree of group. T2; Monterey cyprus (next to T3 along boundary) - Full removal. T3; Sycamore (along footpath - southern boundary mid-way) - Full removal. T4; Sycamore (by postbox corner) - Full removal. T5; Sycamore (along wall to sea) - Reduce by half.

    Granted Trees 10 docs

  • 3 Swains Villas Swains Road Bembridge Isle Of Wight PO35 5XT

    21/01298/HOU Submitted 21 Jun 2021 50 yards away

    Proposed single storey side and rear wrap around extension (revised scheme)

    Granted Householder Extension 14 docs
    Small domestic

  • 7 Frampton Way Bembridge Isle Of Wight PO35 5XX

    23/00185/HOU Submitted 31 Jan 2023 50 yards away

    Proposed alterations to rear conservatory, front door, Infill of porch, and addition of solar panels to the rear roof.

    Granted Householder Extension 12 docs
    Small domestic

  • Swains House Swains Road Bembridge Isle Of Wight PO35 5XT

    26/01250/TW Submitted 9 Sep 2026 100 yards away

    T1; Monterey Pine (Pinus radiata) - Crown clean and thin overhang to garages approximately 20-25%. Reason: Canopy is heavily biased with overloaded boughs. T2; Cedar of lebanon (Cedrus Libani),Crown clean canopy overhanging road; Crown lift over road to approximately 6m height. Reason: To improve safety to pedestrians and high vehicles as overhanging a frequently used road. T3; Bay (Prunus nobilis) - Prune tertiary boughs to provide 1m clearance from BT wires. Reason: To prevent tree damaging BT wires. T4 and T5; Sycamore (Acer pseudoplatanus) - Prune tertiary boughs to provide 1M clearance from BT wires. Reason: To prevent trees damaging BT wires. T6; Sweet Chestnut (Castanea sativa) - Crown lift canopy above Magnolia (Magnoliaceae grandiflora) to approximately 5m. Reason: To reduce overloaded bough overhanging Magnolia (Magnoliaceae grandiflora) and allow it more light. T7; Magnolia (Magnoliaceae grandiflora) - Prune overall canopy approximately 30%. Reason: To regenerate the canopy and provide arboricultural maintenance. T8: Strawberry Tree (Arbutus unedo) - Prune as per photo. Reason: To improve access.

    Granted Trees 7 docs

  • Swains House Swains Road Bembridge Isle Of Wight PO35 5XT

    26/01247/TW Submitted 9 Sep 2026 100 yards away

    **5 Day Notice** T1; White Poplar (Populus alba) - Remove large snapped/hanging bough; reduce overhanging bough back from beach as specified on picture. Reason: To make the tree safe.

    Granted Trees

In Isle of Wight

  • 26/01525/FUL Awaiting decision

    25 Ventnor Road Apse Heath Newchurch Sandown Isle Of Wight PO36 0JT

    Proposed change of use of existing detached office and storage building to provide hairdressing salon/nail bar/beauty treatment (Class E) on first floor

    Received 2 Nov, published by the council 5 Nov 2026 Full applications
  • 26/01505/FUL Awaiting decision

    9 Mount Pleasant Road Newport Isle Of Wight PO30 1EH

    Demolition of single storey extension; Proposed alterations to fenestration and formation of parking for two vehicles

    Received 29 Oct, published by the council 30 Oct 2026 Full applications
  • 26/01488/FUL Awaiting decision

    The Plough And Barleycorn 4 North Road Shanklin Isle Of Wight PO37 6DB

    Proposed extension and alterations to create self contained holiday unit

    Received 26 Oct, published by the council 27 Oct 2026 Full applications
  • 26/01475/FUL Awaiting decision

    42 Worsley Road Gurnard Cowes Isle Of Wight PO31 8JW

    Demolition of existing dwelling; Proposed replacement dwelling and one detached dwelling with associated vehicular access and parking area

    Received 23 Oct, published by the council 29 Oct 2026 Full applications
  • 26/01453/FUL Awaiting decision

    45 Hamilton Road Binstead Ryde Isle Of Wight PO33 3QY

    Demolition of garage; Proposed outbuilding for use as hairdressing salon, with wc and multi-use room

    Received 20 Oct, published by the council 6 Nov 2026 Full applications