Planning application
HGY/2026/0733
33 Hillfield Park, Hornsey, London, N10 3QT
Proposal
Works to tree protected by a TPO. T1 Holm Oak, Quercus ilex in rear garden - fell. After a number of fungi appeared on the tree in 2024 I had a Picus Test performed on the tree in October 2014 which identified decay on the interior of the tree and recommended significant pruning, which was carried out in February 2025. Unfortunately, a number of very large shaggy bracket fungi, Ionotus Hispidus have appeared on the trunk of the tree since then, raising my concern that the health of the tree was continuing to deteriorate. I had the tree assessed again by a qualified tree surgeon in January 2026 and since heavy branches have continued to fall from the tree, to protect the nearby houses and the Marks & Spencer car park to the rear of the garden they have recommended felling of the tree. The tree is 18 metres tall but only 12 metres from the house. I propose to replace the tree and would appreciate your advice on a replacement, bearing in mind the locations proximity to the building. I attach the 2024 Picus test results, the recent tree surgeon's report, a Sketch Plan and supporting photos of the fungi.
As published by the council, reference HGY/2026/0733
Timeline
Dates from the published record
-
16 Mar 2026
Received by Haringey
-
5 May 2026
Decision issued: Refuse
-
24 Jul 2026
Added to PlanIndex
What refusal means
The process from here
The council refused this application for the reasons set out on the decision notice, which the council portal holds in full. Only the applicant can appeal a refusal; the time limit runs from the decision date and is shorter for householder schemes.
Refusal does not prevent a fresh attempt. Applicants often address the reasons for refusal and resubmit, so a refused scheme is not necessarily the end of proposals for the site.
About trees applications
How this application type works
Tree applications cover work to protected trees: those under a tree preservation order need consent for pruning or felling, and trees in a conservation area need six weeks written notice before work starts. The council assesses the amenity value of the tree and can refuse consent, approve it with conditions, or in conservation areas make a preservation order in response.
Nearby applications
Within 500 metres
-
HGY/2026/1470 Granted
33 Hillfield Park, Hornsey, London, N10 3QT
Works to tree protected by a TPO. It is a Holm Oak Tree, Quercus ilex in the rear garden of number 33 Hillfield Park, N10 3QT. After a report from a qualified tree surgeon, I submitted an application to remove the tree but this was rejected. The local authority tree expert reported that The Picus report shows a seam running through the trunk’s base surrounded with ample sound residue wood (as highlighted within the report). There are two large fruiting Ganoderma spp gonks at the base on the compression south side. There is also a smaller bracket approximately 1.5m up the trunk on the west side, and evidence of an old small bracket on the northside between the buttresses. Rather than remove, the Local Planning Authority (LPA) would allow lesser works to reduce further beyond the last most recent reduction points. A 10- 12ft crown reduction above the tree’s break would reduce the sail area, bring the canopy below the surrounding tree line, and allow for the tree to be retained.
-
HGY/2025/3214 Awaiting decision
126-138 Muswell Hill Broadway, Hornsey, London, N10 3RU
Display of 1 x no. externally illuminated fascia sign, 1 x no. externally illuminated hanging sign and 2 x no. vinyls to front and 3 x no. trolley bay signs
-
HGY/2022/4515 Granted
71 Hillfield Park, Hornsey, London, N10 3QU
Replacement of existing single glazed windows and doors to the ground floor flat with new timber double glazed windows and doors to match the existing.
-
HGY/2025/2010 Refused
58A Hillfield Park Mews, Hornsey, London, N10 3QR
Variation of condition 2 (approved plans) of planning permission HGY/2019/3040 for Change of use of building from office and storage space (B1/B8) to Personal Training Studio (D2). Proposed change to remove parking spaces and allow congregation of customers and staff in area infront of building entrance.
-
HGY/2026/0838 Granted
105 & 111 Muswell Hill Broadway, Hornsey, London, N10 3RS
Display of a new Digital Display Screen behind the shopfront window.
-
HGY/2026/0829 Awaiting decision
105 & 111 Muswell Hill Broadway, Hornsey, London, N10 3RS
Display of 1no. internally illuminated projecting hanging sign and 2no. externally illuminated fascia signs, and installation of window film to front elevation.
Other trees applications
In Haringey
-
HGY/2026/2169 Awaiting decision
68 Grove Avenue, Hornsey, London, N10 2AN
T1: Purple plum (8m): Reduce height by 1.5m and shape to keep tree at a size suitable for its location
-
HGY/2026/2160 Awaiting decision
Flat A, 16 Mount View Road, Hornsey, London, N4 4HX
There is a tree in the back garden I believe it’s a type of maple T1 , but not 100%. Its overdue a reduction. I've suggested around 2m off the top and match the sides to create a compound shape. It’s blocking out a lot of light to the end of the garden and is quite close to the buildings at the back.
-
HGY/2026/1486 Granted
87 Hillfield Avenue, Hornsey, London, N8 7DG
Rear garden: General maintenance works: T1: Mature Lime: Approximately 7.00m: Growing within close proximity of the building. Reduce back to previous and most recent pollard points. T2: Hybrid Birch: Approximately 2.50m: Remove dead wood only. T3: Cedar: Approximately 8.00m: Thin crown density by approximately 20-25%. Reduce lateral and sub lateral growth over the pond by up to 1.00m. Tip prune height to reduce by approximately 1.30m. Reduce remaining crown by up to 60cm to shape and balance as required. Rear Left Hand Corner: T4: Ash: approximately 9.00m: Reduce crown back to previous and most recent points of reduction, approximately 1.20m-1.50m. T5: Lime: Approximately 11.00m: Reduce by up to approximately 2.50m, pruning back to suitable growth points. T6: Small Apple: Approximately 3.50m: Reduce by approximately 1.00m. T7 & T8: 2 x Mature Eucalyptus: Approximately 7.00m: Reduce crowns by up to 1.50m to help maintain more compact crown structure. Thin densities by approximately 20%. Remove dead wood throughout the crowns. T9: Robinia Frisa: Approximately 8.00m: Thin crown density by up to 10%. Remove dead wood. Tip prune any overlong branches up to 0.75m back into main crown structure back into the main crown structure. T10: Picea: Approximately 8.00m: Tip prune to reduce crown by up to approximately 1.00m to help control dimensions and clear the crown of the Magnolia adjacent. T11: Magnolia Grandiflora: Approximately 7.00m: Reduce the crown by up to approximately 1.20m to help stimulate lower leaf generation. Remove dead wood. T12: Mature Cork Screw Willow: Approximately 9.00m: Reduce back to previous and most recent reduction/pollard points whilst preserving a suitable amount of furnishing growth to ensure crown continuity. Remove dead wood.
-
HGY/2026/1938 Granted
81 Dukes Avenue, Hornsey, London, N10 2QD
Ash (T1): Reduce to previous, most recent pruning points (approx. 1-2m).
-
HGY/2026/2146 Awaiting decision
70 Sheldon Avenue, Hornsey, London, N6 4ND
T1: Hornbeam - crown reduce by 2-3m back to previous pruning points. T3: Sycamore – crown reduce by 2-3m back to previous.