Skip to content
PlanIndex Get alerts
Menu

Planning application

1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

Refused Elmbridge 2023/0696 Non-Material Amendments

Relates to 2022/0166

Refused. Only the applicant can appeal, within the statutory time limit, and a revised scheme can be submitted instead.

Proposal

Non-Material Amendment to planning permission 2022/0166 to remove promenade roof and change materials of decking and balustrade.

As published by the council, reference 2023/0696

Application record

Reference
2023/0696
Type
Non-Material Amendments
Status
Final Decision
Decision
Refused As published: Non-Material Amendment - Refused
Received
8 Mar 2023
Validated
21 Mar 2023
Decided
18 Apr 2023
Ward
Claygate Ward
Decision by
Officer delegated
Postcode
KT10 0PX

Site history

Applications at this address on the Elmbridge register

This site has had 9 applications since 2019: 6 approved, 3 refused.

  • 2025/3166 Granted

    1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

    Tree Preservation Order EL:94/11 - Eucalyptus Gunnii (T1, EL:94/11) needs to be removed due to fungal growth and consequent root rot. It is approx. 30m tall on a sloping site and is 6m from an inhabited building and 4m from the driveway at 1 Beaconsfield Gardens. Its position on the boundary also poses a risk to the building and driveway at 3 Beaconsfield Gardens. It has been assessed by three professionals who have noted obvious decay by fungi with no treatment possible. The decay has, in the last few months, progressed noticeably more quickly and has now spread 2m up the trunk; work has therefore become more urgent. Replanting another tree in this position would be likely to incur future risk to the neighbouring buildings so is unfortunately not recommended. Work would be as follows: Remove the large Eucalyptus tree that is showing root decay and has started to rot at the base. The tree will be safely lowered and the large timber removed using a grab lorry. Track mats will be provided to protect the driveway and surrounding area.

    Decided 13 Jan 2026 Trees
  • 2025/2355 Granted

    1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

    Tree Preservation Order EL:94/11 - T4 Oak Remove The tree works are proposed to stop the influence of the tree(s) on the soil below building foundation level and provide long term stability.to 20 Beaconsfield Road Esher Surrey KT10 0PW Estimated costs of repair to the building are £103,000.00 if the influence of the tree(s) remain and £11,923.68 if the proposed tree works are allowed to proceed. Granting permission will limit these costs. In the event of a refusal we, or our clients, will seek to secure compensation for the additional costs incurred through Section 202(e). Should the tree/s remain the total cost of repairs will be the Superstructural repairs + Alternative method of repairs = £114,923.68 It is the expert opinion of both the case engineer and arboriculturalist that on the balance of probabilities the supporting information demonstrates the influence of the tree(s). Note: Further monitoring results may be submitted if these become available during the course of this application.

    Decided 3 Nov 2025 Trees
  • 2023/1488 Granted

    1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

    Variation of Condition 2 (Approved Plans) and 3 (Materials) of planning permission 2022/0166 (Rear extension and raised decking) to remove promenade roof and change materials of decking and balustrade.

    Decided 25 Aug 2023 Amendments
  • 2023/0544 Granted

    1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

    Claygate Foley Estate Conservation Area - Fell 1 x Prunus (T011).

    Decided 11 Apr 2023 Trees
  • 2022/0166 Granted

    1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

    Rear extension, raised decking and alterations to fenestration following demolition of existing conservatory.

    Decided 22 Apr 2022 Householder
  • 2021/1224 Refused

    1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

    Rear outbuilding incorporating swimming pool, new rear raised decking with roof above and relocation of external staircase following demolition of existing decking.

    Decided 1 Jul 2021 Householder
  • 2020/0336 Granted

    1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

    Tree Preservation Order EL: 97/11 - Crown thin 1 x Cedar (T3) by 20%.

    Decided 17 Mar 2020 Trees
  • 2019/2595 Refused

    1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

    Tree Preservation Order EL: 97/11 Crown reduce - 1 x Eucalyptus by 6m in height and 4m in spread and 1 x Yew - by 1.5m in height and 1.5m spread, crown thin 1 x Cedar by 20% and remove dead wood.

    Decided 5 Dec 2019 Trees

Timeline

Dates from the published record

  1. 8 Mar 2023

    Received by Elmbridge

  2. 21 Mar 2023

    Validated

    Checked as complete and ready for consideration.

  3. 18 Apr 2023

    Decision issued: Non-Material Amendment - Refused

  4. 19 Aug 2026

    Added to PlanIndex

Cases linked to this one on the register

  • 2022/0166 Granted

    1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

    Rear extension, raised decking and alterations to fenestration following demolition of existing conservatory.

    Decided 22 Apr 2022 Householder

Documents

Plans, drawings, consultee responses and the officer's report

12 documents on file for this application

A planning file usually holds the application form, drawings and site plans, consultee responses, the officer's report and the decision notice.

Watch members (£5 a month) open the document list from here.

Open the documents

What this refusal means

Elmbridge refused this application for the reasons on the decision notice; only the applicant can appeal, and refused schemes often return in revised form. More in our guide to what happens after a planning decision.

About amendment applications

An amendment application makes limited changes to a permission that already exists; anything beyond modest adjustment needs a fresh application. More in our guide to planning application types.

Nearby applications

Within 0.3 miles

  • 1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

    2023/0544 Submitted 22 Feb 2023 50 yards away

    Claygate Foley Estate Conservation Area - Fell 1 x Prunus (T011).

    Granted Trees 6 docs
  • 1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

    2020/0336 Submitted 10 Feb 2020 50 yards away

    Tree Preservation Order EL: 97/11 - Crown thin 1 x Cedar (T3) by 20%.

    Granted Trees 5 docs
  • 1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

    2025/2355 Submitted 15 Sep 2025 50 yards away

    Tree Preservation Order EL:94/11 - T4 Oak Remove The tree works are proposed to stop the influence of the tree(s) on the soil below building foundation level and provide long term stability.to 20 Beaconsfield Road Esher Surrey KT10 0PW Estimated costs of repair to the building are £103,000.00 if the influence of the tree(s) remain and £11,923.68 if the proposed tree works are allowed to proceed. Granting permission will limit these costs. In the event of a refusal we, or our clients, will seek to secure compensation for the additional costs incurred through Section 202(e). Should the tree/s remain the total cost of repairs will be the Superstructural repairs + Alternative method of repairs = £114,923.68 It is the expert opinion of both the case engineer and arboriculturalist that on the balance of probabilities the supporting information demonstrates the influence of the tree(s). Note: Further monitoring results may be submitted if these become available during the course of this application.

    Granted Trees 10 docs
  • 1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

    2022/0166 Submitted 21 Jan 2022 50 yards away

    Rear extension, raised decking and alterations to fenestration following demolition of existing conservatory.

    Granted Householder Extension Demolition +1 22 docs
    Small domestic
  • 1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

    2025/3166 Submitted 3 Dec 2025 50 yards away

    Tree Preservation Order EL:94/11 - Eucalyptus Gunnii (T1, EL:94/11) needs to be removed due to fungal growth and consequent root rot. It is approx. 30m tall on a sloping site and is 6m from an inhabited building and 4m from the driveway at 1 Beaconsfield Gardens. Its position on the boundary also poses a risk to the building and driveway at 3 Beaconsfield Gardens. It has been assessed by three professionals who have noted obvious decay by fungi with no treatment possible. The decay has, in the last few months, progressed noticeably more quickly and has now spread 2m up the trunk; work has therefore become more urgent. Replanting another tree in this position would be likely to incur future risk to the neighbouring buildings so is unfortunately not recommended. Work would be as follows: Remove the large Eucalyptus tree that is showing root decay and has started to rot at the base. The tree will be safely lowered and the large timber removed using a grab lorry. Track mats will be provided to protect the driveway and surrounding area.

    Granted Trees 7 docs
  • 1 Beaconsfield Gardens Claygate Esher Surrey KT10 0PX

    2019/2595 Submitted 16 Sep 2019 50 yards away

    Tree Preservation Order EL: 97/11 Crown reduce - 1 x Eucalyptus by 6m in height and 4m in spread and 1 x Yew - by 1.5m in height and 1.5m spread, crown thin 1 x Cedar by 20% and remove dead wood.

    Refused Trees 6 docs

In Elmbridge

  • 2026/1677 Refused

    Laurelwood Cavendish Road Weybridge Surrey KT13 0JY

    Variation of Condition 4 (Tree Protection Measures) and 5 (Site Supervision) of planning permission 2025/1959 (Detached two-storey house with attached garage and associated landscaping following demolition of the existing house) to amend Tree Protection Plans and Tree Planting & Hard Surfaces Plan within approved arboricultural report.

    Received 8 Jul, published by the council 30 Jul 2026 Amendments
  • 2026/2363 Awaiting decision

    Land off Anyards Road and Copse Road Cobham Surrey KT11 2LH

    Non-Material Amendment to planning permission 2025/0373 to revise the landscape plan to remove the trees from the rear gardens of plots 1-8 and replace them within management controlled areas.

    Received 30 Sep, published by the council 7 Oct 2026 Amendments
  • 2026/1471 Granted

    15 Chaucer Avenue Weybridge Surrey KT13 0SS

    Variation of Condition 2 (Approved Plans) of planning permission 2025/3172 (Single-storey side and rear extension and extended patio following partial demolition of existing house) to relocate patio stairs and extend patio with an additional stepped level and balustrades.

    Received 17 Jun, published by the council 30 Jul 2026 Amendments
  • 2026/2340 Awaiting decision

    Weybridge Health Centre 22 Church Street Weybridge Surrey KT13 8DW

    Non-Material Amendment to planning permission to 2024/3065 to remove existing wall on part of the western boundary, relocation of bin store and partial reconstruction of the removed wall and to amend the wording of Conditions 8 (Cycle Parking), 15 (SuDS Verification) and 26 (Habitat Management and Maintenance Plan) to specify 'completed development'.

    Received 29 Sep, published by the council 7 Oct 2026 Amendments
  • 2026/2333 Awaiting decision

    103 Grange Road West Molesey Surrey KT8 2PR

    Removal of Conditions: 5 (Tree Protection Measures) and 6 (Site supervision) of 2024/3083 (Single-storey rear extension, rear dormer window and alterations to fenestration following partial demolition of rear projection) to remove tree conditions based on the findings of the report as the original conditions cannot be complied with.

    Received 29 Sep, published by the council 7 Oct 2026 Amendments