Skip to content
PlanIndex Get alerts
Menu

Planning application

3 Midvale Road Paignton TQ4 5BD

Refused Torbay AT/2024/0270 Works To Tree Within CA

Works: Trees Domestic

Read from the description, not a valuation. How we read the register

Refused. Only the applicant can appeal, within the statutory time limit, and a revised scheme can be submitted instead.

Proposal

T1 - X1 Mature Walnut - Reduce overall canopy of the tree; Reduce the height of the tree by approximately x2.0 metres leaving a final tree height of approximately x10.0 metres. Reduce radial canopy spreads by approximately x2.0 metres leaving a final radial crown spread of approximately x10. metres at all compass points. Pruning wounds shall not exceed x80 mm in diameter. The tree dominates the rear garden and the canopy touches the dwelling & causes excessive shading over the property & garden area.

As published by the council, reference AT/2024/0270

Application record

Reference
AT/2024/0270
Type
Works To Tree Within CA
Status
Decided
Decision
Refused As published: Refusal
Received
4 Oct 2024
Validated
7 Oct 2024
Decided
7 Nov 2024
Ward
Roundham With Hyde
Decision by
Delegated
Postcode
TQ4 5BD

Timeline

Dates from the published record

  1. 4 Oct 2024

    Received by Torbay

  2. 7 Oct 2024

    Validated

    Checked as complete and ready for consideration.

  3. 7 Nov 2024

    Decision issued: Refusal

  4. 1 Aug 2026

    Added to PlanIndex

Who's behind it

Company information only, from the register and Companies House

Devon Tree Services Ltd Agent, a tree-works contractor registered in Torquay

Active · incorporated 2013 · Torquay

153 applications on PlanIndex · across 10 councils · 85% granted

Trade members see everything this firm has filed, how it was decided, and get an email the day it files again.

See their track record

Documents

Plans, drawings, consultee responses and the officer's report

2 documents on file for this application

A planning file usually holds the application form, drawings and site plans, consultee responses, the officer's report and the decision notice.

Watch members (£5 a month) open the document list from here.

Open the documents

What this refusal means

Torbay refused this application for the reasons on the decision notice; only the applicant can appeal, and refused schemes often return in revised form. More in our guide to what happens after a planning decision.

About tree works applications

Applications for works to trees cover protected trees: consent under a tree preservation order, or six weeks notice for trees in a conservation area. More in our guide to planning application types.

Nearby applications

Within 0.3 miles

  • Jasmyn House 1 Midvale Road Paignton TQ4 5BD

    P/2020/0396 Submitted 24 Mar 2020 50 yards away

    Installation of decking to front elevation to provide disabled access and fire escape.

    Withdrawn Full applications 20 docs
  • 41 Totnes Road Paignton TQ4 5LA

    P/2026/0532 Submitted 24 Aug 2026 50 yards away

    77% historically approved · decision due ~21 Oct

    Change of use from ambulance offices (use class E) to residential institution as adult respite centre (use class C2) to include construction of single storey extension to rear and associated works.

    Awaiting decision Full applications Extension
    Small domestic
  • 20 Curledge Street Paignton TQ4 5BA

    AT/2021/0254 Submitted 21 Jul 2021 50 yards away

    T003: Lime - Fell due to extensive decay and location.

    Granted Trees 3 docs
  • Mayfield Medical Centre 37 Totnes Road Paignton TQ4 5LA

    AT/2026/0063 Submitted 24 Feb 2026 100 yards away

    T1 - Eucalypt (Fell) Reason for Removal: The tree is growing within a confined raised bed, providing insufficient space for future root plate expansion. This constraint has already resulted in structural interaction with the retaining wall, indicating ongoing and likely progressive damage. A fruitbody of Spectacular Rustgill (Gymnopilus junonius) was noted at the base, suggesting possible decay activity within the root zone. Given the tree's position adjacent to the driveway and pedestrian access, the combination of restricted rooting environment, structural pressure on built features, and potential root decay presents an unacceptable risk to vehicles and pedestrians. Removal is therefore recommended.

    Decided Trees
  • Grosvenor Court 19 Grosvenor Road Paignton TQ4 5AZ

    AT/2025/0277 Submitted 12 Sep 2025 100 yards away

    T001 - Whitebeam prune back off side of property. T002 Whitebeam- crown lift t o 3 metres over pavement. T003 - Apple - prune back off car parking space or remove whole tree completely.

    Granted Trees
  • 13 Curledge Street Paignton TQ4 5BA

    P/2026/0326 Submitted 19 May 2026 150 yards away

    Change of use of existing dwellinghouse (Use Class C3) to a small-scale supported accommodation use (Use Class C2) for up to three young people aged 16-18, with associated staff support. No external alterations.

    Refused Full applications
    Domestic

In Torbay

  • AT/2026/0248 Decided

    Holtye Stitchill Road Torquay TQ1 1PZ

    5 Day Notice T1 - Dead pollarded Holm Oak (Quercus ilex) Sectionally dismantle, fell and remove dead tree, leaving the cut stump at a finished height of approximately 1.0 metre abou ground level.

    Received 15 Sep, published by the council 17 Sep 2026 Trees
  • AT/2026/0245 Awaiting decision

    Flat 1 Kingsbridge Greenway Road Torquay TQ1 4NJ

    T001 - Mature Beech (Fagus sylvatica) Observations: Mature beech with a substantial fungal fruiting body present at the base of the stem, visually consistent with Ganoderma spp. Sounding of the lower stem with a sounding mallet produced a pronounced hollow response extending from the base to approximately 2 m above ground level on the road-facing side, indicating potentially significant internal dysfunction and decay within the lower main stem. The defect is located within the tree?s primary load-bearing region, where the main stem transfers crown loading into the root system. Decay or loss of sound wood in this area is therefore considered structurally significant. The full extent of internal decay and remaining residual wall thickness could not be quantified through ground-based inspection alone. The tree supports a large mature crown and is located immediately adjacent to a public highway, with pedestrians, moving and parked vehicles, and nearby residential properties within the potential failure zone. Recommendation: Dismantle T001 to near ground level. The recommendation is based on the presence of basal fungal decay, the pronounced hollow response extending approximately 2 m up the lower stem, and the location of the defect within the principal load-bearing region of the tree. These findings materially reduce confidence in the tree's long-term structural reliability. Although the tree provides significant local amenity value within the Conservation Area, this is considered outweighed by the extent and structural significance of the identified defects and the potential consequences of whole-tree or basal failure onto the adjacent highway and surrounding targets.

    Received 10 Sep, published by the council 17 Sep 2026 Trees
  • AT/2026/0246 Awaiting decision

    Coniston Lodge Rowdens Road Torquay TQ2 5AZ

    Tree is Holm oak, see photos. Photo shows tree and then position in red dot to house Application is to thin the tree by 25 to 30 % (crown) and prune to clear overhead utility cables by 1 m . This work is required every couple of years to keep the tree healthy and so as not to interfere with cables to house.

    Received 10 Sep, published by the council 17 Sep 2026 Trees
  • AT/2026/0242 Granted

    Upton Manor Orchard Upton Manor Road Brixham TQ5 9RB

    5 Day Notice Removal of large dead Spruce tree Removal of dead Cherry tree See Photos

    Received 8 Sep, published by the council 17 Sep 2026 Trees
  • AT/2026/0214 Granted

    Alta Vista Higher Warberry Road Torquay TQ1 1SD

    Recent emergency approved felling of two older Lime trees in next door neighbour's garden precipitated a check on our own Lime Tree sic. Precautionary Work is requested on Trunk 2 of a large mature Lime Tree in south part of our property. Sketch Plan Lime Tree position refers . The Lime tree has 4 Trunks from ground level - numbering from left to right in provided Photo Lime Tree 1 of 4 Trunk 2. Photo Lime Tree 2 of 4 shows vis discoloration separation of Trunk 2 from Trunk 3. Separation >=12cm August 2026. No previous measurement. Photo Lime Tree 3 of 4 shows southern inclination of Trunk 2 and extended southern branch growth giving increasing weight leverage/imbalance. Photo Lime Tree 4 of 4 shows extent of recent years Beefsteak fungus at base of Trunk 2 - width c 25cms August 2026. Condition of Lime Tree discussed on site with Jamie, Trees in Need who has managed bi-annually maintenance on our trees for c 20 years. Fungal infection currently appears to be on Trunk 2 base but Trunk 2 is closely twinned with Trunk 3 at this level. Trunk 3 is however largely vertical and foliage more balanced and therefore less at longer term risk. So Imminent/emergency danger of Trunk 2 failure not likely but following precautionary action suggested Requested permission for following Action for Trunk 2. Remove all top growth c 6/7 meter level as show in Photo Lime Tree 3 where extended South lateral growth is prominent to provide a largely vertical Trunk with reduced weight /leverage . Continue to monitor Trunk 2 & 3 separation and Fungal growth.

    Received 12 Aug, published by the council 23 Aug 2026 Trees